This is what it could have looked like…
An app that uses the Bureau’s covert war data to alert people to the far reaches of the US government’s secret wars has been blocked from Apple’s app store.
Drones+, the creation of NYU student Josh Begley, was meant to be a simple way of notifying users whenever US drones struck somewhere in the world.
But Apple decided this was not acceptable for its customers. After rejecting the app on the grounds of its design and functionality, the US tech giant finally took exception to its content.
In correspondence seen by the Bureau, the US tech giant told Begley that apps that ‘present excessively objectionable or crude content will be rejected.’
The company added: ‘We found that your app contains content that many audiences would find objectionable.’
‘We found that your app contains content that many audiences would find objectionable.’ Apple correspondence
Apple’s decision did not come as a surprise to Begley. ‘I think their position is often just they don’t want to let anything through that could be seen by anyone at any particular table that could be seen as controversial,’ he said.
But how its content could have been objectionable or crude for a user is difficult to fathom.
A basic app, Drones+ was simply a news feed summarising each entry from the Bureau’s databases and a map of the drone strikes. Each time a drone hits a village in Waziristan, a message would ping straight to the user’s handset to let them know.
Inane nudges
The project began with a simple question about what smartphone users like to be notified about.
Begley wondered if US smartphone users would want to be told about something more challenging than ‘the sort of inane nudges you get when it’s your turn to play Words With Friends.’
He presumed not. But Apple, who could not be reached for comment on this story before publication, has made sure he will never know.
Following their latest rejection Begley is abandoning the Apple app idea. He is thinking about producing a version for the rival Android system instead.
But iphone users were of specific interest to Begley. Having schooled himself on the extent of the US drone programme, he says he wanted to push the drone debate ‘into corners where it hasn’t been discussed.’
Smartphone users more interested in the nuts and bolts of technology may go for an Android phone, he explains. Apple’s products appeal to a different crowd.
‘I think people who use iphones like them because “they just work,”’ he says. ‘Part of the reason they just work is because Apple is either very vigilant or diligent…to shape and control every aspect of the experience.’
Thanks to a handful of high profile leaks, US drones are getting some attention. But Begley believes there is a limit to how much people understand, himself included. Before starting to make the app, ‘I had a general sense of hidden drone wars but never actually had a granular understanding,’ he says.
From the start of the project one line of the drones debate grabbed his attention. ‘When I started thinking about the app I actually didn’t know about the Bureau’s data sets,’ he explains. ‘I was considering using New America Foundation’s data.’
But as the accuracy of New America Foundation’s data was challenged in the media, Begley turned to the Bureau. ‘In light of recent questions of their under reporting, and their potentially severe under reporting, it just made sense to use the best data set around.’
Unfortunately, it just isn’t coming soon to an Apple Store near you.
Sign up for email alerts from the Bureau here.
August 30th, 2012 at 8:24 pm (#)
‘It contains content that many audiences would consider objectionable’, many people in Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia object to being killed by US drones carrying out extra-judicial killings. Many of the people murdered are children, women and rescuers attempting to render first-aid. Very often the drones loiter overhead just so they can target those coming to offer help. I object to the United States carrying out these illegal murders.
August 31st, 2012 at 12:43 am (#)
I’ll write one for the windows phone. Do you have an API I can link to?
August 31st, 2012 at 11:46 am (#)
Anything else instead for Android? Apple cannot stop this kind of initiatives.
August 31st, 2012 at 2:48 pm (#)
It is very sad to see how the businesses in US support government and hide reality from the people. This is way they had in USSR.
August 31st, 2012 at 7:01 pm (#)
Why don’t you just make a web app that runs in a browser. Seems like the very least you could do to better present the data on this website, not to mention that it couldn’t be blocked by Apple if it ran in a browser.
August 31st, 2012 at 11:52 pm (#)
Why not try Cydia? Make it available to jailbroken phones?
September 1st, 2012 at 3:54 am (#)
So what? 70% of smartphones are running Android. iOS only accounts for about 22%. You’re developing for the wrong platform in more ways than one.
September 2nd, 2012 at 2:17 pm (#)
@ J. Kerppo: This is way they had in USSR
…you mean: This is was the HAVE in Russia, Belarus, Ukraine, e.a.
September 3rd, 2012 at 2:53 am (#)
Sounds like whining, this should be for Android, not iOS.
Where’s the Android version on the market??? People have been searching for it…
September 5th, 2012 at 11:17 pm (#)
Seriously, the fact that this was obviously developed by an Apple fanboy is sad. Then there is whining when the overlords reject it. This entire situation is a typical Apple-type experience. I reject it all. Hopefully this press will cause a non-Apple fanboy to write a real app for Android which of course is the platform for freedom.
September 7th, 2012 at 11:55 pm (#)
Seems to me that this is both a source of information, an editorial of sorts, and a powerful protest. Apple may not like it, but I hope someone else is willing to make it available. If seeing the results of drone strikes is “objectionable”, imagine what it must be like to be on the receiving end of one. Are you listening, Apple?